It's being discussed and I'm curious of the viewpoints of Conservatives out there.  Please speak out and comment below:

According to recent reports, lawmakers are considering a proposal that would allow all taxpayers to claim the charitable deduction, rather than just those that itemize. Currently, about 70 percent of U.S. households choose to take the standard deduction, which means that they forgo the opportunity to deduct their charitable contributions. Under this proposal, the charitable deduction would become an “above-the-line” deduction, available to all taxpayers, whether or not they itemize.

This proposal is particularly relevant in the context of Republican tax reform proposals that would cause fewer taxpayers to itemize their deductions. Both the House Republican “Blueprint” and the Trump administration proposal would greatly increase the standard deduction and eliminate many itemized deductions. These two changes would lead many taxpayers to choose to take the standard deduction instead of itemizing, which would decrease the number that claim the charitable deduction. The House Blueprint, for instance, specifically aims to reduce the number of taxpayers that itemize “to approximately 5 percent.”

For some, the fact that the House Blueprint would lead fewer taxpayers to claim the charitable deduction is a feature, not a bug. After all, a major goal of tax reform is to decrease the size and scope of deductions and other targeted provisions in the tax code, in order to broaden the tax base and lower marginal rates. However, others are wary of any tax changes that would reduce the usage of the charitable deduction, which could lead to fewer charitable contributions.

Making the charitable deduction into an above-the-line deduction would make it more widely available, but would also come with trade-offs. For one thing, doing so would reduce federal revenue, because more taxpayers would be able to reduce their taxable income by deducting charitable contributions. We estimate that, under current law, making the charitable deduction above-the-line would reduce federal revenue by $191 billion over ten years.

Change in federal revenue from converting the charitable deduction to an above-the-line deduction (2017-2026)
In the context of current law In the context of the House GOP Blueprint
Source: Tax Foundation, Taxes and Growth Model (March 2017 version). Estimates assume no change in household charitable giving.
-$191 billion -$515 billion

In the context of the House Blueprint, the revenue loss from making the charitable deduction above-the-line would be even greater, $515 billion over ten years. This is because the overall structure of the House Blueprint would cause so many taxpayers to take the standard deduction and to stop claiming the charitable deduction. Thus, making the charitable deduction above-the-line would effectively restore the deduction for these taxpayers, which is why doing so would be so costly in the context of the House Blueprint.

These revenue estimates assume that modifications to the charitable deduction would not result in changes to household charitable giving levels. In reality, making the charitable deduction above-the-line would likely lead to higher charitable contributions by U.S. households, which means that the true cost of this proposal is probably higher than the estimates shown above.

Another trade-off associated with this proposal is that it would slightly alter the distribution of the federal tax burden. For instance, in the context of current law, making the charitable deduction into an above-the-line deduction would deliver the largest benefits to households in the top 1 percent, as well as to middle-income households. In the context of the House Blueprint, the benefits of making the charitable deduction above-the-line would be even more skewed toward high-income earners.

Change in after-tax income by quintile from converting the charitable deduction to an above-the-line deduction
  In the context of current law In the context of the House GOP Blueprint
Source: Tax Foundation, Taxes and Growth Model (March 2017 version). Estimates assume no change in household charitable giving.
0% to 20% 0.01% 0.00%
20% to 40% 0.07% 0.11%
40% to 60% 0.16% 0.25%
60% to 80% 0.17% 0.35%
80% to 100% 0.14% 0.48%
90% to 100% 0.13% 0.47%
99% to 100% 0.20% 0.50%
ALL 0.14% 0.38%

One other interesting consequence of making the charitable deduction into an above-the-line deduction is that doing so would almost certainly lead to decreased usage of the home mortgage interest deduction. This is because, if the charitable deduction were no longer an itemized deduction, fewer households would decide to itemize. As a result, fewer households would claim the home mortgage interest deduction.

Courtesy of the TaxFoundation

You need to be a member of The Constitutional Conservatives to add comments!

Join The Constitutional Conservatives

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Help Support TCC

This is a member-supported website. Your contribution is greatly appreciated!

Follow Us!

Not receiving your emails from us? Internet security continues to tighten in today's hacker world.

Be sure to ADD us to your email provider contacts list. mail@theconstitutionalconservatives.com mail@912communique.com

Don't Forget The Tags

NOTE TO CONTRIBUTORS

Don't forget your tags.  Tags in an article are INCREDIBLY important!    They're the internets way of finding your post in a search.

Without tags - your article is INVISIBLE on the web!

Use keywords found within your post and/or use phrases which a person would enter *IF* they were searching your topic.

For examples click here.

 

Please don't be shy!

1. Read the Rules

2. Read "How To" Add Content/Discussions

TCC Wonders.....

Random, thought-provoking topics.  Take your pick and give us your Conservative view.

 

  • The "fundamental change" to Socialism/Communism?
  • Thoughts on Immigration
  •  TRUE and HONEST Voting
  • The Deep State
  • AOC and the Gang
  • Have any Summer rally plans?  Tell us about them.
  •  There is so much crazieness out there- take your pick- let's talk about it!!